Want to Die? You’ll Have to Wait
From the desk of Paul Belien on Tue, 2006-08-08 08:47
Belgium is one of the few countries where the liberal agenda has been pushed so far that, apart from abortion and gay marriage, euthanasia is also allowed by law. However, “market failure” is now jeopardizing the right of Belgians to die. The standard euthanasia procedure in Belgium (as in the Netherlands) is through injection with an overdose of the drug Pentothal. Brussels’ leading euthanasiast, Prof Wim Distelmans, complained in the Belgian press today that the supply of the drug to Belgium has all but stopped since Abbott Laboratories, the American pharmaceutical company that used to produce Pentothal, transferred the production to its spin-off Hospira in 2004.
The cause, apparently, is the packaging of the drug. So far Pentothal was sold in packets of ten ampullas, while one or two ampullas suffice to kill. Hospira has decided to start selling packets of only one ampulla in Belgium, but while the old packets have been sold out the new are not yet available. Hospira refused to comment but the reason for the change in packaging may be that the Belgian pro-euthanasia authorities are no longer willing to reimburse Pentothal unless it is sold in single doses.
“We have been without Pentothal for weeks now,” Distelmans complains, adding that there is no alternative to the drug. “The intention of euthanasia is to bring the patient into an in an irreversible coma in an elegant and reliable manner. Pentothal is the only drug which can do this.”
Belgian pharmacies confirm that there is a shortage of Pentothal. According to the leftist newspaper De Morgen the shortage may last for three months or more, depriving people of their right “to die in dignity,” unless Pentothal is bought abroad.
Belgian doctors register 30 cases of euthanasia every month, though Distelmans suspects that most euthanasia deaths are not registered as such. He estimates that the actual number of people killed through euthanasia is five times as high.
It's not a failure of the
Submitted by Brigands on Wed, 2006-08-09 14:00.
It's not a failure of the market, there are plenty of alternatives. From 5.56mm NATO to 9mm. Pillows work too if applied with sufficient force, ask the Federales. Then there's overdrugging someone...no need for professional killer drugs. Too cynical?
Market failure??
Submitted by marcfrans on Tue, 2006-08-08 16:35.
It is not obvious that this is a case of "market failure".
From the above description it would seem that there is only 1 supplier of the drug in question. That suggests that there is no genuine "market" on the supply side. One would have to delve deeper into the reason(s) for this supply monopoly before one could call this a case of "market failure".
It would also appear that almost ALL the buyers of the drug get "reimbursed" by the Belgian authorities. That suggests that there is also no genuine "market" on the demand side, but rather a monopsony.
Perhaps, this is a case of "regulatory failure" or "governmental failure"? Since there is no market in play here.